REEPORT, Me., March 4 — Attendance is up.
Detentions are down. Just six months after Maine began a
controversial program to provide laptop computers to every
seventh grader in the state, educators are impressed by how
quickly students and teachers have adapted to laptop
technology.
In a language arts class at Freeport Middle School, for
example, muted howls could be heard recently as students
researched projects related to Arctic stories, including "The
Call of the Wild" by Jack London. Following Internet tracks
created by their teacher, Janice Murphy, some students,
inspired by the story, were researching wolves.
"Look," said Doug Hoover, 13, double-clicking on a wolf
site. "Here's a picture of the sound waves the wolf makes when
it howls."
Here and at the 239 middle schools around the state,
students, teachers and parents say they are finding unexpected
benefits.
No one seems more surprised by the early success of the
program than Angus King, the state's former governor. When he
announced the plan in the summer of 2000, motivated by a $50
million budget surplus and a pressing need to attract new
business to Maine, Mr. King was stunned by the vehemence of
objections.
The statewide effort, the first of its kind in the nation,
"was more controversial than abortion, gay rights or even
clear cutting," Mr. King said. "People hated it. They thought
it was extravagant; they thought the kids wouldn't take care
of the computers."
An early opponent was Chellie Pingree, then the State
Senate majority leader and soon to be the president of Common
Cause, a government watchdog group based in Washington. "It
was about the allocation of resources," Ms. Pingree said. "We
were struggling with construction issues: schools needed to be
built; there were leaky roofs and not enough books."
Though she now sees the program as a success, others still
say it is misguided.
"The state was flush at the time the laptop program was
inaugurated, when it should have been providing for the rainy
day that we're living with today," said Sumner Lipton, a
lawyer in Augusta and a former state legislator. "There's a
certain degree of irony in giving all the seventh graders
laptops in a day when we're talking about cutting state
employees back to four-day work weeks."
Before the program began, legislators trimmed its cost and
scope. Envisioned as a $50 million effort that would let
seventh graders take the computers with them through
graduation, the plan was limited to seventh and eighth
graders.
Laptops will follow their users to eighth grade next year,
while seventh graders will get new iBooks, for a total of
33,000. When students leave the eighth grade, they will turn
them in.
The cost of the four-year program is $37.5 million, which
includes leasing the laptops, installing wireless ports
throughout schools so students are always connected to the
Internet and training teachers. It translates to about $300
per user a year, said Tony Sprague, project manager of the
laptop program, the Maine Learning Technology Initiative.
To bolster the program, Mr. King sought support from beyond
the state government. The author Stephen King (who is not
related to Angus King) toured the Freeport school and offered
to teach an online writing course. The Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation donated $1 million for more teacher training. The
technology giant EDS pledged $400 million in software for
Maine schools, the biggest gift the state has ever
received.
Educators say that problems have been minimal, with little
breakage, theft or loss. The rewards, teachers say, have been
impressive.
"These laptops are changing the way learning happens and
the way teaching happens," said Chris Toy, principal of
Freeport Middle School. Such a transformation, Mr. Toy said,
can happen only when each student has a computer. "We don't
have a pencil lab or put eight pencils in the middle of the
room and have kids take turns using them, Computers are tools,
and when every child in every school has one, it levels the
playing field."